Nine wishes for 2009 #6: the EU to get real

Share This

You never know, it’s just possible this might happen.

2008 presented a real quandary for me: on the one hand, I was (not uncritically) supportive of the European Constitutional Treaty. Its mutation into the Lisbon Treaty made it weaker still, removing one of the main advantages of the Constitutional Treaty in the first place (specifically, that it was a clean slate and relatively easy to read compared to trying to follow a succession of amending treaties), but on balance it contained just enough good things in it for me to have voted “yes” in any referendum.

On the other hand, such a referendum was not forthcoming. I may be pro-European, but I’m also a democrat. I don’t believe the only way of ratifying a treaty like Lisbon is to hold a referendum, but we needed some kind of procedure to ratify it which recognised it was more than just another act of Parliament. There are many ways this could have been done – a super majority in both House of Parliament or two votes on either side of a general election – but fundamentally, the vote would have been lost whichever way you did it. And just to add an extra layer of cynicism, the Lib Dems came up with this idea of having a referendum on membership as a whole, knowing that neither of the other parties would back it, just so they could have a figleaf to put on their Focus leaflets.

And all that I could live with if the pro-European parties were prepared to stick their necks out and actually argue the case for European Union. Except they don’t, fearing it will make them unpopular.

Either way, by June it looked like this whole sorry exercise was over. Then, Ireland threw a spanner in the works by – uncharacteristically – voting “no” in their own referendum. Since then we have been in limbo, with no-one seeming to have a clue what to do next.

Unlike some, I don’t think Ireland’s decision to now have a second referendum is undemocratic. If the political class in Ireland feel confident that the public will change their mind and vote accordingly second time around, that is fine with me. I’m amazed they’re doing it though; if I were Irish I’d be very tempted to vote “no” just to spite them. The money is on a second “no” vote surely; isn’t it just delaying the inevitable.

The whole debacle is part of a wider failure of the EU’s political class to provide leadership on, well, pretty much anything over the past decade (Timothy Garton Ash showed the extent of the EU’s failure in his Guardian column last week). Enlargement and the Euro have been successes but all the heavy lifting for both of those we done in the nineties. All we’ve had since then is a lot of petty squabbling and a tunnel vision obsession about fiddling with the institutions.

This needs to change, finally, in 2009. Following the second Irish referendum the Lisbon Treaty will be either alive or as dead as dead can be; the zombie-shuffle of the past six months will finally be at an end. The first thing we have to take steps to ensure is that some of the more dim EU leaders don’t start drawing up plans for a Son-of-Lisbon Treaty. Instead, we have got to make do with what we have.

Secondly, we have major challenges to tackle. Immediately, there is the Middle East Crisis of course. By the end of 2009 we have the replacement of the Kyoto Protocol to worry about. And then of course there is how we deal with Russia, Turkey, the Balkans, the global economic downturn… all of these amount to a clear need for the EU to get serious and stop dicking around.

The Lib Dems can do their bit by campaigning in the European Parliamentary elections as an actual pro-European party rather than trying to dazzle people with irrelevancies. The decision to run the elections at the same time as the County Council elections won’t make this easy, and if we have a general election as well, debate about Europe will more or less dry up completely. But after spending 2008 in such a mess, it would be good to see us finally articulating an unambiguously positive vision for Europe. No-one else is going to.

3 thoughts on “Nine wishes for 2009 #6: the EU to get real

  1. If by “campaigning… as an acutal pro-European party” you mean openly saying that European action is a good thing and that Europea can be a better force for good if more Lib Dem MEPs are elected than I can reassure you that is eactly the sort of campaign all our Euro canditates are determined to fight.

    In November I spoke at 13 local party AGMs and called for a pro-European campaign on relevant issues. It was interesting how well that was received.

    Most acitivsts want us to be more prooudly pro-European and know that the strategy in 2004 of talking about state issues like schools and hospitals was a disaster.

  2. The various ruling bodies of the EU as a desperately need to sort themselves out and do more to connect with the people of Europe.

    The Lib Dems can (and hopefully will) play an important role in that by campaigning for an EU as it should be.

  3. I should tell you that as a conservative minded EUsceptic, the LibDem argument has greater democratic resonance than either of the other two parties. Because LibDems see the benefits of the EU and are prepared to argue those benefits in an open debate, whereas Labour and Conservatives want to keep the issue of below the radar.

    My last MP was LibDem and I had greater respect for his position than I do his Conservative replacement who merely mouths anti – EU platitudes.

    It is a shame that your leader did not take the opportunity to stand by these principals of open debate and vote for a referendum.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *